How
far do Elon Musk and
Reform UK share a
political vision?
How far do Elon Musk and Reform UK share a political vision?
Ben Quinn and Dan Milmo
Immigration, culture wars and shrinking the public sector all feature highly
on their agendas
Sun 22 Dec 2024 15.41 GMT Last modified on Sun 22 Dec 2024 15.44 GMT
Share
The get-together last week of Elon Musk, Nigel Farage and Reform UK’s
treasurer, Nick Candy, wasn’t just a gathering of Donald Trump fans. It was a
meeting of minds.
Immigration, culture wars and shrinking the public sector all feature highly
on their political agendas, developed under the umbrella of Trump’s Maga
vision.
“We only have one more chance left to save the west and we can do great things
together,” said Farage afterwards.
It also revived speculation that Musk could donate as much as $100m to Reform
UK, even if there are signs that such a move might actually be opposed by
voters.
A ban on wealthy foreign nationals being able to give large sums of money to
British political parties was backed by 55%, according to a survey by
Survation for the campaign group 38 Degrees.
Asked specifically about Musk, two-thirds (66%) said he should not become
influential in British politics• Политика. Even among Reform UK voters, 51% did not want
to see Musk become influential.
Money aside though, the ideological common ground between Musk and Reform UK
is clear in some areas.
Immigration
Musk is a vocal critic of US immigration policy, making him a natural
ideological bedfellow with Reform UK. Referring to the US-Mexico border this
year, he said “unvetted immigration at large scale is a recipe for disaster”
and called for a “secure southern border”. However, he also called for
“greatly expediting legal immigration”, reflecting US tech industry concerns
about labour needs.
Immigration is a core concern for Farage and Reform UK. Its top pledge in its
manifesto-style “contract” with voters during the UK general election this
year was to freeze all “non-essential” immigration.
The second pledge was to detain and deport illegal immigrants, including
sending arrivals on small boats “back to France”.
Shrinking the government
Musk – whose grinding of an anti-government axe dates back to his own feelings
that regulations have hampered his car making and space rocket businesses –
has been given licence by Donald Trump to cut $500bn from the US federal
budget.
He and fellow billionaire Vivek Ramaswamy are heading a new Department of
Government Efficiency , or Doge – named with a winking nod to Musk’s
cryptocurrency• Экономика » Финансы » Платежные средства » Платежные системы интернета » Криптовалюта of choice, dogecoin• Экономика » Финансы » Платежные средства » Платежные системы интернета » Криптовалюта » Dogecoin.
Farage has been quick out of the gates to endorse this. Trump’s plans to
radically slash the US public sector and appoint Musk to “sack vast numbers of
people” were a blueprint for what needed to happen in the UK, the Reform UK
leader said last month.
Elon Musk handpicked by Trump to carry out slash-and-burn cuts plan
Read more
Tim Bale, a professor of politics• Политика at Queen Mary University of London• Объект организация » Организации по алфавиту » Организации на Ло » Лондонский Университет Королевы Марии, said
part of Reform UK’s appeal to Musk is its “disruptor” status, echoing the
character of a serial entrepreneur who does not shy away from confrontation.
“The main appeal of Reform• Политика » Реформа for Musk is that they are disruptors and he likes
disruptors,” he said. “He just likes the fact they are shaking things up.”
Rights and the ‘war on woke’
Musk has told of making a vow to “destroy” what he describes as “the woke mind
virus” after his estrangement from his trans daughter, Vivian Wilson.
The topic is one that the billionaire has repeatedly returned to during
tweets, waging other culture wars on diversity regulations.
Farage placed issues and arguments around gender on the very first page of his
party’s general election manifesto earlier this year, referring to a “divisive
‘woke’ ideology” that he claimed had captured public institutions.
Reform UK pledged to ban what it calls “transgender ideology” in schools
within the first 100 days of government. It also pledged to replace the
Equality Act and says it would scrap diversity, equality and inclusion rules.
“Clearly, Musk has got a bee in his bonnet about the trans issue in particular
and the so-called woke mind virus in general, and that dovetails well with the
Reform UK position on the culture wars,” said Bale.
Net zero
As the chief executive of the world’s leading electric car brand, Musk has
strong environmental credentials. But Musk has made more ambivalent noises
about green issues recently. In a discussion with Trump on X in August, Musk
said it was “wrong” to vilify the fossil fuel sector.
In terms of existential threat, Musk has also shown more interest in low birth
rates and artificial intelligence as problems requiring the world’s attention.
This was a change from his view in 2018 when he said that climate change• Политика » Геополитика » Международные отношения » Направления международного сотрудничества » Изменение климата
• Метеорология » Климатология » Изменение климата was
“the biggest threat that humanity faces this century”.
Farage’s photo with Musk and Nick Candy defines his Trump tribute act era
Read more
Reform UK advocates rolling back environmentally friendly policies. It has
pledged to scrap the UK’s 2050 net zero target – where the UK removes as much
carbon dioxide from the atmosphere as it emits – because it is “crippling our
economy”.
The party also pledges to fast-track North Sea oil and gas licences, as well
as doing more to enable fracking.
Russia• Россия
Musk has moved from being an initial supporter of Ukraine• Украина to a more ambiguous
position, which has included trolling• Общество » Социальные группы » Субкультура » Сетевой жаргон » Троллинг
• Коммуникации » Интернет-коммуникации » Сетевой этикет » Троллинг the country’s president, Volodymyr
Zelenskyy.
In 2022, the billionaire sparked outrage when he floated a “peace plan” in
which he argued that Ukraine• Украина should adopt a neutral status and drop a bid to
join Nato• Политика » Геополитика » Военно-политические блоки » НАТО
• Объект организация » Организации по алфавиту » Организации на на » НАТО.
While Musk’s Starlink satellite internet service was used to help Ukraine• Украина
after Russia• Россия’s February 2022 invasion, there was also controversy last year
when it emerged that Musk had refused a Ukrainian request to activate the
system to assist in a surprise offensive.
Farage has faced criticism over his claims that Ukraine• Украина could not defeat
Russia• Россия and his questioning of a US decision to authorize Kyiv to use
long-range missiles.
Past comments by the Reform UK leader, such as that the EU and Nato• Политика » Геополитика » Военно-политические блоки » НАТО
• Объект организация » Организации по алфавиту » Организации на на » НАТО had
“provoked” Russia• Россия’s invasion of Ukraine• Украина by expanding eastwards, have also put
him at odds with other mainstream political parties in the UK.